MilanFan009
A.P.7.
- Joined
- Sep 5, 2006
- Messages
- 1,127
- Reaction score
- 0
- Location
- Montreal, Canada
- Fav. Players
- Kaka', Gattuso, Maldini, Nesta, Pato, Buffon
On the news a couple of days ago, there was a story about baseball getting a camera review but only on a certain play to help clarify the calls. Like if they aren't sure if it is a home run or not they check the cameras and replays to make the right call.
My question to you is, do you think football (soccer) should get the same thing? Should the refs be allowed to check the cameras to see if it was a goal or not? Or let's say if they think that there is a penalty but they check the cameras and see that the player dove.
I think that it SHOULDN'T be allowed. This sport has existed for hundreds of years and this is what makes football. Sure it may be fair, but that is not football. Football is full of controversy, but that's what makes it an even more beautiful sport. If your team gets a bad call and they lose the CL Final but then the year after they win it, the win is more rewarding and it's like revenge. You are even happier then if you would win regularly. You have a ref, two linesmen, and a fourth official. People are only human, this is a human sport where people make mistakes. This is the art of football, what do you talk about with your friends after a game? How it was a penalty, or how it wasn't, or maybe he dove or he didn't. With the cameras, it wouldn't be the same.
FIFA was talking about putting cameras in the goal or even at one point putting a sensor in the ball so that if it senses it passes the line it informs the ref. I think that is utter crap.
What are your views?
My question to you is, do you think football (soccer) should get the same thing? Should the refs be allowed to check the cameras to see if it was a goal or not? Or let's say if they think that there is a penalty but they check the cameras and see that the player dove.
I think that it SHOULDN'T be allowed. This sport has existed for hundreds of years and this is what makes football. Sure it may be fair, but that is not football. Football is full of controversy, but that's what makes it an even more beautiful sport. If your team gets a bad call and they lose the CL Final but then the year after they win it, the win is more rewarding and it's like revenge. You are even happier then if you would win regularly. You have a ref, two linesmen, and a fourth official. People are only human, this is a human sport where people make mistakes. This is the art of football, what do you talk about with your friends after a game? How it was a penalty, or how it wasn't, or maybe he dove or he didn't. With the cameras, it wouldn't be the same.
FIFA was talking about putting cameras in the goal or even at one point putting a sensor in the ball so that if it senses it passes the line it informs the ref. I think that is utter crap.
What are your views?