Preferred Formation

Which formation ?

  • 4-3-2-1

    Votes: 140 36.6%
  • 4-3-1-2

    Votes: 242 63.4%

  • Total voters
    382

liberogrande

Licensed Hattrick Coach
Joined
May 12, 2002
Messages
750
Reaction score
0
Location
China where catastrophes strike all the time
Fav. Players
Filippo INZAGHI/大因札吉/F.インザ-ギ
hey... have you people got shocked by the formation that Carlo Ancelotti made against Lokmotiv?

Finally he had realized that JDT could be a OFFENSIVE MIDFIELD!!!!!!
i knew he could do well in that position,he just had been in that role when he played for feyenoord.
well if he keep this up and make up the 'JDT-sheva-pippo' combination,that would be absolutely gorgeous...
 

juninho-paulista

rubro-negro
Joined
Sep 11, 2002
Messages
1,709
Reaction score
2
Location
Geneva/Sydney
Fav. Players
Timmy Cahill and Mr. Leite
libreogrande said:
hey... have you people got shocked by the formation that Carlo Ancelotti made against Lokmotiv?

Finally he had realized that JDT could be a OFFENSIVE MIDFIELD!!!!!!
i knew he could do well in that position,he just had been in that role when he played for feyenoord.
well if he keep this up and make up the 'JDT-sheva-pippo' combination,that would be absolutely gorgeous...

ANY formation with JDT in it is undesirable :rolleyes: but i think he would make a great orange peeler for our champ players at half time!

Ive theoried a new formation inspired by my all time favourite game (Besides Age of Mythology and SimCity) Champ Manager: Its a 3-4-1-2 using a playmaker and a 3-5-2 using wingers :cool:

3-4-1-2

----------------------------------------Dida----------------------------------------
------------Nesta--------------------Maldini---------------------Kaladze---------
---Gattuso-----------Seedorf-------------------Pirlo-----------------Serginho--
-------------------------------------Rui Costa-------------------------------------
---------------------Shevchenko---------------Inzaghi--------------------------

(also can be changed up to allow Rivaldo, i.e 3-4-2-1 swapping Sheva/Pippo for Rivaldo who would go back with Rui to support the one striker)..

3-5-2

----------------------------------------Dida----------------------------------------
------------Nesta--------------------Maldini---------------------Kaladze---------
Seedorf---------Gattuso-----------Rui Costa--------Pirlo---------------Rivaldo
-------------------------Shevchenko--------Inzaghi------------------------------

(Rui costa would journey forward also, but emphasis would be put on the wings patrolled by Riva and Clarence, who arent really all out wingers, which suggest further need for established widemen. The right is more important because we have Sergio on the left)

Milan e solo Rossonero :devil: (my italian is non-existant)
 
Joined
Feb 19, 2003
Messages
90
Reaction score
0
Location
malaysia
=============abbiati=============
=======nesta==========maldini=====
simic=======================kaladze
=============seedorf=============
=======pirlo==========rui costa=====
=============rivaldo=============
=======shevchenko=====pippo=======

all right?
 

THeJaMmi1

Starting Eleven
Joined
May 26, 2002
Messages
285
Reaction score
0
Location
via Turati, 3 - 20121 - Milano
apis7ac7sheva7 said:
=============abbiati=============
=======nesta==========maldini=====
simic=======================kaladze
=============seedorf=============
=======pirlo==========rui costa=====
=============rivaldo=============
=======shevchenko=====pippo=======

all right?

my friend, i think that that could be a bit too agressive and offensive...i know nesta maldini are good and all, but they aint that good!

and also just saying....i know our team is versatile aswell, but we can't play rui at leeft midfield, and pirlo right midfiel...i'm sorry mate..
 

ferruginouz

Milan Veteran
Joined
Dec 28, 2002
Messages
1,170
Reaction score
0
Location
Batavia
THeJaMmi1 said:
apis7ac7sheva7 said:
=============abbiati=============
=======nesta==========maldini=====
simic=======================kaladze
=============seedorf=============
=======pirlo==========rui costa=====
=============rivaldo=============
=======shevchenko=====pippo=======

all right?

my friend, i think that that could be a bit too agressive and offensive...i know nesta maldini are good and all, but they aint that good!

and also just saying....i know our team is versatile aswell, but we can't play rui at leeft midfield, and pirlo right midfiel...i'm sorry mate..

This particular scheme should use in games againts team which deffence a lot
 
Joined
Jan 12, 2003
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Location
England
-----------------abbati--------------
----------junior nesta Maldini---------
Pirlo redondo seedorf Sergnhino-----------
-----------------Rui----------------------
--------------Sheva Rivaldo-------------
 

THeJaMmi1

Starting Eleven
Joined
May 26, 2002
Messages
285
Reaction score
0
Location
via Turati, 3 - 20121 - Milano
Renaissance said:
-----------------abbati--------------
----------junior nesta Maldini---------
Pirlo redondo seedorf Sergnhino-----------
-----------------Rui----------------------
--------------Sheva Rivaldo-------------

ok again sorry for being picky

but i have to say, if one is going to write a dream team down then try to make it as realistic to the players positions as possibl

how can pirlo play on the right!

it just is not compatible!

this aint champ manager u know!
 

rony31

Starting Eleven
Joined
Jan 23, 2003
Messages
426
Reaction score
0
Location
Toronto, Canada
Dida
Anyone but Simic, Nesta, Maldini, Kakha
Gattuso, Seedorf, Pirlo, Serginho
Inzaghi, anyone who's not playing as shit as Sheva, Riva, and Rui Cosa currently are :rolleyes:
 

azira

Starting Eleven
Joined
Jan 16, 2003
Messages
436
Reaction score
0
heh..should we put Rivaldo for the rest?
i think he's too tired and gattuso is the best choice
cos he's able to move almost in full time.
 

PB

Beginner
Joined
Mar 20, 2003
Messages
58
Reaction score
0
Abiatti

Simic, Nesta, Maldini, Kaladze

Gattuso, Seedorf, Rui Costa, Rivaldo

Inzaghi, Shevchenko
 

kharrazian

Primavera
Joined
May 6, 2002
Messages
242
Reaction score
0
Location
Iran
PB said:
Abiatti

Simic, Nesta, Maldini, Kaladze

Gattuso, Seedorf, Rui Costa, Rivaldo

Inzaghi, Shevchenko

Rivaldo doesnt like to play as left midfielder.You dont remember his discussions with Van Gaal when he was in Barcelona? If he accepts to play in left side that is a good formation and line up.
--------------------------------------------------------
I think Simic doesnt deserve to play fixed in Milan.Milan needs a skillfull right back like Thuram or my favourate right defend player Melchiot.
There is another way.Carletto can use Gattuso in right back.Then Seedorf or Brocchi or Ambrosini will play in as right midfielder.
 

PB

Beginner
Joined
Mar 20, 2003
Messages
58
Reaction score
0
kharrazian said:
PB said:
Abiatti

Simic, Nesta, Maldini, Kaladze

Gattuso, Seedorf, Rui Costa, Rivaldo

Inzaghi, Shevchenko

Rivaldo doesnt like to play as left midfielder.You dont remember his discussions with Van Gaal when he was in Barcelona? If he accepts to play in left side that is a good formation and line up.
--------------------------------------------------------
I think Simic doesnt deserve to play fixed in Milan.Milan needs a skillfull right back like Thuram or my favourate right defend player Melchiot.
There is another way.Carletto can use Gattuso in right back.Then Seedorf or Brocchi or Ambrosini will play in as right midfielder.


Well Rivaldo must play where the trainer says and I have to say that he was playing in this position when he got the Golden Ball. At all Melchiot could be a good sign up, but I prefer Bonera, Milan has to have the best Italians plus 2 or 3 of the best players in the world.
 

DonippoKakaShevdini

Santo Baresi
Joined
Sep 12, 2002
Messages
3,065
Reaction score
4
Fav. Players
Der Franco
PB said:
Melchiot could be a good sign up

This is great. Just the sort of comic relief I had been in search for.

Mario Melchiot always wanted to become a football player badly........and he has fully realized his dream......he has become a bad footballer. Poorous at best.

Serie A Strikers would expose this man's horrendous defending to a point you can only imagine.
 

kharrazian

Primavera
Joined
May 6, 2002
Messages
242
Reaction score
0
Location
Iran
RivippoRuiNestaShevdini said:
PB said:
Melchiot could be a good sign up

This is great. Just the sort of comic relief I had been in search for.

Mario Melchiot always wanted to become a football player badly........and he has fully realized his dream......he has become a bad footballer. Poorous at best.

Serie A Strikers would expose this man's horrendous defending to a point you can only imagine.

Donatello,I dont agree with your comments about Melchiot.He has all characteristics of a good defender.At least he is better than Simic or Helveg.

Masimo Oddo is a talent right back too.I havent seen his matches recently but I have heard he is a promising young player.
 

DonippoKakaShevdini

Santo Baresi
Joined
Sep 12, 2002
Messages
3,065
Reaction score
4
Fav. Players
Der Franco
kharrazian said:
RivippoRuiNestaShevdini said:
PB said:
Melchiot could be a good sign up

This is great. Just the sort of comic relief I had been in search for.

Mario Melchiot always wanted to become a football player badly........and he has fully realized his dream......he has become a bad footballer. Poorous at best.

Serie A Strikers would expose this man's horrendous defending to a point you can only imagine.

Donatello,I dont agree with your comments about Melchiot.He has all characteristics of a good defender.At least he is better than Simic or Helveg.

Masimo Oddo is a talent right back too.I havent seen his matches recently but I have heard he is a promising young player.

Thats fair. But personally.....people said Winston Bogarde and Michael Reizinger were going to be great defenders too. Both of them look and play very similar to Mario Melchiot.

Another thing too.....the Dutch aren't really known for producing defenders......historically that is.

Seriously, when Stam, Hofland, and De Boer is what your country can boast about during the topic of defensive talismen.....well then.......it might be better to keep quiet...... :)

BUT.......if the topic of discussion switches to attack-minded players.....

UP THE DUTCH ;)

ORANJE
 

kharrazian

Primavera
Joined
May 6, 2002
Messages
242
Reaction score
0
Location
Iran
Imagine that one day Galliani telephones you! :o and asks you to introduce him a good right back.He tells you that the maximum budget of club to buy a right back is 10 million dollars. Then which player will you recommend him?

If he asks me,I will advise him to exchange Rui Costa with Thuram!
If Van Der Vaart joins Milan in summer there will be no place for Rui between first 11 players of squad.He is getting old so his price in transfer market is decreasing.So summer is the best time to sell him or exchange him with a player which club needs.Besides Milan wont pay money to get Thuram.That will be saving in money too.
 

mad4milan

Milan Veteran
Joined
Dec 27, 2002
Messages
1,364
Reaction score
0
Location
Canada
kharrazian said:
PB said:
Rivaldo doesnt like to play as left midfielder.You dont remember his discussions with Van Gaal when he was in Barcelona? If he accepts to play in left side that is a good formation and line up.

Well Rivaldo must play where the trainer says and I have to say that he was playing in this position when he got the Golden Ball.
I agree. Rui and others agreed to play different positions in order to help the team. I don't see why Riva shouldn't either.

kharrazian said:
Imagine that one day Galliani telephones you! :o and asks you to introduce him a good right back.He tells you that the maximum budget of club to buy a right back is 10 million dollars. Then which player will you recommend him?
How about Paulo Ferrera?? Young, very good and cheap.
 

DonippoKakaShevdini

Santo Baresi
Joined
Sep 12, 2002
Messages
3,065
Reaction score
4
Fav. Players
Der Franco
mad4milan said:
kharrazian said:
Imagine that one day Galliani telephones you! :o and asks you to introduce him a good right back.He tells you that the maximum budget of club to buy a right back is 10 million dollars. Then which player will you recommend him?
How about Paulo Ferrera?? Young, very good and cheap.

10 million euros would probably be enough to secure Bonera too.
 
Joined
Apr 3, 2003
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
-----------------dida--------------------
simic------nesta------maldini----kaladze
gattuso---seedorf---redondo----rivaldo
---------------rui costa--------------------
----------sheva------inzaghi-------------
 

PB

Beginner
Joined
Mar 20, 2003
Messages
58
Reaction score
0
sheva07 said:
-----------------dida--------------------
simic------nesta------maldini----kaladze
gattuso---seedorf---redondo----rivaldo
---------------rui costa--------------------
----------sheva------inzaghi-------------

Very nice I did not notice before that the solution to our problems is playing with twelve, is a good solution always that our opponents remain with the traditional 11 players formation.
 

Maldini3

Starting Eleven
Joined
Apr 3, 2003
Messages
529
Reaction score
0
Location
crm crm crm
Fav. Players
The Old Man
PB said:
sheva07 said:
-----------------dida--------------------
simic------nesta------maldini----kaladze
gattuso---seedorf---redondo----rivaldo
---------------rui costa--------------------
----------sheva------inzaghi-------------

Very nice I did not notice before that the solution to our problems is playing with twelve, is a good solution always that our opponents remain with the traditional 11 players formation.
:D :devil2: :devil:
But now Seedorf is out.. :cry: Hope that Pirlo wil soon be available :mad:
-----------------------Dida--------------------------
Simic-------Nesta------------Maldini------Kaladze
Gattuso-------------Pirlo---------------Ambrossini
-------------------Rui Costa------------------------
--------------Inzaghi------Sheva-------------------

I know that some positions are not OK but we are now in danger of injurues. :mad: :head: :(
 

Andressa M (Bra)

Starting Eleven
Joined
Mar 10, 2003
Messages
385
Reaction score
0
Location
Brazil
Fav. Players
Kaká, Ronaldo, R. Carlos, J. César, Maldini
Ok
Here goes my formation:

----------------------------------------Dida


Simic---------------Nesta-----------------Costacurta-------------------Maldini


-------------Gattuso-------------Redondo--------------------Brocchi
------------------------------------------Rui Costa


-----------------------Rivaldo (Sheva?)-------------Inzaghi



If you do like (or don't) :head: Write me.

Goodbye ;)

Milan Rocks
Inter Sucks :mad:
 
Joined
Feb 19, 2003
Messages
90
Reaction score
0
Location
malaysia
===========dida==============
====nesta===========maldini====
simic====================kaladze
===========pirlo=============
====rui=============seedorf====
===========riva=============
====sheva==========pippo======

ok?
 

juninho-paulista

rubro-negro
Joined
Sep 11, 2002
Messages
1,709
Reaction score
2
Location
Geneva/Sydney
Fav. Players
Timmy Cahill and Mr. Leite
Well i have a *new and improved!* formation for after the "potential" summer buys...

Abbiati

(Summer Purchase) Nesta Maldini

Kaka Seedorf Pirlo Van der Vaart

Rui/#Diego/*Deco

Shevchenko Inzaghi

# Denotes young player (Diego) to be used for smaller games as part of his development in Europe (If purchased from Santos)

* Denotes desired playmaker, can only possibly take place if Rui leaves the club and Deco himself chooses Milan over other contenders for his signature

As you can see it is 3-4-1-2 and i use it in CM with great success, although i have Andres D'alessandro instead of Rui/Diego/Deco and use Djibril Cisse instead of Shevchenko/Inzaghi (depending on form) :D
 
Joined
Apr 9, 2003
Messages
7
Reaction score
0
Location
Netherland
Rex said:
Post your best formation. :)

-----------------------------------Dida---------------------------------------------

----------------------------------Nesta--------------------------------------------
----------------------Maldini ----------------Kaladze-----------------------------
-----------------------------------Pirlo---------------------------------------------
------Seedorf--------------------------------------------Serghino----------------
----------------------Rui Costa---------Rivaldo-----------------------------------
--------Shevchenko---------------------------Inzaghi----------------------------

This is how milan must play because all opponents play wit 1 or 2 strikers
so we dont need 4 or 5 defenders. We need attacking football with players who can play 1 touch football en have creative instinct just like Real Madrid but this MILAN will be MUCH BETTER. and for Rivaldo he is not a striker he is a number 10 player just like Rui Costa,so you will have two numbers 10 players a right footplayer(Rui Costa) and a left footplayer(Rivaldo)and then you will see the real Rivaldo.And for Seedorf and Serghino they must keep the field very wide so you heva more space to play attacking football.BECAUSE THE BEST DEFENCE IS ATTACK.and there is no arguing about this is the only way this milan can and must play.I hope that Carlo Ancelotti and Silvio Berlusconi read this mail so we can finally see a Milan ply like in the good old days.

The biggest MILAN fan of all times.
 

sheva7

Milan Veteran
Joined
Jul 21, 2002
Messages
1,096
Reaction score
0
Location
Israel, Ashdod
------------------------------------Dida----------------------------------

------Simic-------------NEsta-----------Maldini--------------Kaladze

----------------------Gattuso------------Pirlo----------------------------

-----------------Rui---------------------------Seedorf------------------------

-------------------Pipo-------------------Sheva-----------------------------
 

kaiser

Beginner
Joined
Nov 10, 2002
Messages
64
Reaction score
0
Location
India
--------Costacurta-------Nesta-----------Maldini

----------------Gattuso----------Pirlo----------

-------Rui Costa--------Seedorf---------Rivaldo

--------------Sheva----------------Inzagi--------

When u've got 3 top quality defenders, U can spare a wing back for repositioning. The back 3 with the help of Gattuso & Pirlo can hold the attacks...while Rui and Riva can set up the front 2 with Seedorf providing assistance where ever required
This formation is definitely a bit different!
 

Stiff_vs_Mr_Oerk

Starting Eleven
Joined
Sep 2, 2002
Messages
271
Reaction score
0
Location
Hillerød, Denmark
Well - the best seasonal team of the year must be:
Dida
Costacurta
Nesta
Maldini
Kaladze
Gattuso
Pirlo
Rui Costa
Seedorf
Shevchenko
Inzaghi

FORZA MILAN :devil:
 

Milanina

Starting Eleven
Joined
Apr 24, 2003
Messages
513
Reaction score
0
Location
Milano - Italia
My preferred formation is:

--------------------Dida------------------
Costacurta---Nesta---Maldini---Kaladze
-----------------Pirlo----------------------
Gattuso-----Rui Costa----------Seedorf
---Shevchenko--------Inzaghi----------

:devil2:

*** I'm agree with Stiff_vs_Mr_Oerk***
 
Top