Official: Andre Miguel Valente da Silva Thread

dcfcfan1 · Apr 24, 2018

If we play with one up front he will struggle here tbh

If we play 4-3-1-2, then I can see him being a star

Hugh Janus · Apr 27, 2018

Sage said:
biggest flop in this club's history

true

plssss Wolverhampton

leaf · Apr 27, 2018

Calling 22 year old Andre Silva a flop for scoring 10 goals in 39 games in his first season, in a Milan which is clearly in chaos is beyond stupid.

For reference:
Kluivert scored 6 in 27 and Elber didn't even get to play for Milan

Sage · Apr 27, 2018

Hugh Janus said:
true

plssss Wolverhampton

sell him as soon as an offer comes

Massaro94 · Apr 27, 2018

Grinitistas calling one of our top goalscorers a flop :lol:

leaf · Apr 27, 2018

Massaro94 said:
Grinitistas calling one of our top goalscorers a flop

Yeah...it's very dumb...especially given that he's probably had the least minutes on the pitch

Kalinic 5 goals in 36 apps
Silva 10 goals in 39 apps
Cutrone 15 in 42 apps

Any reasonable thinker would see that we should replace Kalinic ASAP and try to get more out of Silva and Cutrone.

Sage · Apr 27, 2018

flairtistas counting 8 goals vs EL amateur sides

Congo Powers · Apr 27, 2018

the genoa and chievo goals were nice...i don't think he did anything else 2nd half of the season

leaf · Apr 27, 2018

You know you're a low level troll when you have to borrow other posters' signature memes to make a point.

Again, an assessment of Silva has to be within the context of his team, his age, the league

Kalinic hasn't even scored vs the supposedly amateur sides...but Sage is calling Silva the "biggest flop in this club's history" Since 2017 Kalinic has scored 2 goals for his country but people are harping on about how bad Silva is. 0 fucking goals in 5 or 6 apps... vs the same supposedly amateur teams of the Europa League. This is the level of the forum now.

There was a time when trolling was an offense. Now we have mods like Sage who do nothing but troll at the lowest levels imaginable

Congo Powers · Apr 27, 2018

he's not trolling at all...andre silva was an expensive flop this year brah

Massaro94 · Apr 27, 2018

leaf said:
You know you're a low level troll when you have to borrow other posters' signature memes to make a point.

Again, an assessment of Silva has to be within the context of his team, his age, the league

Kalinic hasn't even scored vs the supposedly amateur sides...but Sage is calling Silva the "biggest flop in this club's history" Since 2017 Kalinic has scored 2 goals for his country but people are harping on about how bad Silva is. 0 fucking goals in 5 or 6 apps... vs the same supposedly amateur teams of the Europa League. This is the level of the forum now.

There was a time when trolling was an offense. Now we have mods like Sage who do nothing but troll at the lowest levels imaginable

First year in Italy... already hit double digits for Milan = all time flop

Meanwhile we've conceded more goals than genoa, couldn't keep a clean sheet vs Benevento and Arsenal despite shelling 40m on bonucci :proud:

Congo Powers · Apr 27, 2018

his contributions to our europa league campaign will be appreciated for many years henceforth

leaf · Apr 27, 2018

Congo Powers said:
he's not trolling at all...andre silva was an expensive flop this year brah

Andre Silva was a flop if you remove all context.
Even you haven't done that by including the "this year" part of your post.
He said "in the club's history" which is the opposite.

Massaro94 said:
First year in Italy... already hit double digits for Milan = all time flop

Meanwhile we've conceded more goals than genoa, couldn't keep a clean sheet vs Benevento and Arsenal despite shelling 40m on bonucci

Sage never had a mean word to say about Bonucci no matter how shit he played....let's not forget his constant shitting on Romagnoli

Sage said:
by far and away, the worst defender of all time.

captain malakia better bench him for paletta or gomez

...it's almost like these distinguished gentlemen calling themselves moderators aren't too fond of Milan :monto:

Sage said:
I feel bad for him, imagine going from chiellini as your partner to a sunday league tier player.

he can still save his career tho, it's not too late.

Sage · Apr 27, 2018

Congo Powers said:
his contributions to our europa league campaign will be appreciated for many years henceforth

ibelongtomilan · Apr 27, 2018

Congo Powers said:
he's not trolling at all...andre silva was an expensive flop this year brah

flop

ya you expect a 21 yos comes to this team and become a savior, no, unless you pay 200M for a 28 yo player you wont get that srsly :lol:

its simple young players are inconsistent and take time for them to adapt for the club

you bought a young player, dont give him time to prove, and sell them to cut losses, thats what a tinpot club do, barca paid the price tripple more than silva for dambele, guess what he barely plays this season, goals and assists combined are not even 10, not to mention barca squad is way better than us :fp:

ok just sell silva and please dont buy young players anymore if you dont know how to use them :fp:

blame all the shit on the player meanwhile the grinta coach has no responsibility :lol:

Congo Powers · Apr 27, 2018

did i expect like alex pato....who only played half a season, and scored 9 goals in serie a, as an 18 year old??

not quite..but i expected more than what we got

ibelongtomilan · Apr 27, 2018

leaf said:
...it's almost like these distinguished gentlemen calling themselves moderators aren't too fond of Milan

Ya, seems like they are more fond of ladri's rejects :proud:

Roma carried Bonucci's asses this season tbh, he made countless mistakes this season :fp:

30yos " world class " player Bonucci played like shit 3/4 of the season and Silva is the biggest flop :proud:

ibelongtomilan · Apr 27, 2018

Congo Powers said:
did i expect like alex pato....who only played half a season, and scored 9 goals in serie a, as an 18 year old??

not quite..but i expected more than what we got

so what?
silva still scored 10, and this is his first season :lol:

you are talking like pato is a some random young players, he has countless potential and was a very talented player :lol:

pato 20-21 years old is easily 150m+ player in today market
silva might not be as talented as pato but he still has much potential, is this fair to call him a biggest flop? :lol:

if you call silva a flop so what do you call a guy in World fucking XI played like shit most of the time? :proud:

Congo Powers · Apr 27, 2018

wat do u mean 'so what'....i told u, i expected more than 2 league goals from andre silva this year...he was disappointing

Ronin · Apr 27, 2018

Congo Powers said:
did i expect like alex pato....who only played half a season, and scored 9 goals in serie a, as an 18 year old??

not quite..but i expected more than what we got

this

Also, don't compare him to Kalinic to make him look good. It's like comparing human shit to horse shit. Even Cutrone, who's not spectacularly gifted did better than him, without any senior football experience.

Massaro94 · Apr 27, 2018

Crisitiano Ronaldo aka DA GOAT... only managed to score 15 goals (90 gmaes) across all comps in his first 2 seasons at Manchester United.

Congo Powers · Apr 27, 2018

Massaro94 said:
Crisitiano Ronaldo aka DA GOAT... only managed to score 15 goals (90 gmaes) across all comps in his first 2 seasons at Manchester United.

fernando redondo scored 5 goals in 225 matches for real madrid

leaf · Apr 27, 2018

*sigh* Now it's a full on troll war :rolleyes:

leaf · Apr 27, 2018

Congo Powers said:
did i expect like alex pato....who only played half a season, and scored 9 goals in serie a, as an 18 year old??

not quite..but i expected more than what we got

C'mon dog....few ppl shat on Pato as much as you did.

ibelongtomilan said:
so what?
silva still scored 10, and this is his first season
you are talking like pato is a some random young players, he has countless potential and was a very talented player
pato 20-21 years old is easily 150m+ player in today market
silva might not be as talented as pato but he still has much potential, is this fair to call him a biggest flop?
if you call silva a flop so what do you call a guy in World fucking XI played like shit most of the time?

You might not want to enter this troll battle with Congo and Sage.
Congo is just enjoying himself and Sage is just trying to provoke for the hell of it.

Ronin said:
this Also, don't compare him to Kalinic to make him look good. It's like comparing human shit to horse shit. Even Cutrone, who's not spectacularly gifted did better than him, without any senior football experience.

We have three strikers. He hasn't delivered as much as Cutrone...but he's been much better than Kalinic. This. Is. Context.

It's important....because, as a barometer, if another player had scored double the goals Silva had, with a similar or less apps then we could definitively say that Silva had flopped. As it is, Cutrone, who has been here longer than him, has scored 5 more goals with 3 more apps....that's insufficient information to say that he flopped....He DID, however perform better than Kalinic by scoring 5 more goals than him in three more apps.

This is his first year in Italy. He's had a new league, language etc to deal with.

Massaro94 said:
Crisitiano Ronaldo aka DA GOAT... only managed to score 15 goals (90 gmaes) across all comps in his first 2 seasons at Manchester United.

"Time to settle in" is a concept unheard of at R&B

ibelongtomilan · Apr 27, 2018

Congo Powers said:
fernando redondo scored 5 goals in 225 matches for real madrid

Congo Powers · Apr 27, 2018

leaf said:
C'mon dog....few ppl shat on Pato as much as you did.

You might not want to enter this troll battle with Congo and Sage.
Congo is just enjoying himself and Sage is just trying to provoke for the hell of it.

right right....you mean when his career ground to a halt and he left europe to return to brazil at age 24, i wrote about him differently than when he was a debutante..funnily enough i think the pato thread is still here!!

here's to hoping andre silva scores more like a 18/19/20 year old pato next season :beer:

Sage · Apr 27, 2018

current retired pato playing football with his chinese friends is at least 5x the player andre silva is

hopefully next season 23 year old andre silva can score 15 goals against professional opposition as 18 year old cristiano ronaldo did playing as a winger in a flat 4-4-2.

Massaro94 · Apr 27, 2018

Congo Powers said:
fernando redondo

Sage said:
biggest flop in this club's history

.

leaf · Apr 27, 2018

Why would someone want the

biggest flop in this club's history

to stay on and play another season and score goals :conf:

Surely if a player was the

biggest flop in this club's history

you would want to get rid of him ASAP. I know for sure I want Kalinic gone yesterday.

It would seem to me that if you want a player to improve, and score more goals in the future, he might indeed not be the

biggest flop in this club's history

Ronin · Apr 27, 2018

leaf said:
We have three strikers. He hasn't delivered as much as Cutrone...but he's been much better than Kalinic. This. Is. Context.

It's important....because, as a barometer, if another player had scored double the goals Silva had, with a similar or less apps then we could definitively say that Silva had flopped. As it is, Cutrone, who has been here longer than him, has scored 5 more goals with 3 more apps....that's insufficient information to say that he flopped....He DID, however perform better than Kalinic by scoring 5 more goals than him in three more apps.

This is his first year in Italy. He's had a new league, language etc to deal with.

"Time to settle in" is a concept unheard of at R&B

Are you really counting the goals against farmers?

Silva scored only 2 goals against real teams, Kalinic 5 (2.5x more) and Cutrone 7 (3.5x more). What are we even discussing here?

I hope to be proven wrong, but I really don't see him becoming anything close to great. He's shown no promise.

I am really confused as how he got so many fanboiz. Unless you are all gay, it makes no sense.

Official: Andre Miguel Valente da Silva Thread

Milan Legend

Paolo Mongdini

Sack Pioli

Phase 3

Milan Legend

Sack Pioli

Phase 3

⭐⭐

Sack Pioli

⭐⭐

Milan Legend

⭐⭐

Sack Pioli

Phase 3

Bohemian Rhapsody

⭐⭐

Bohemian Rhapsody

Bohemian Rhapsody

⭐⭐

Milansochist

Milan Legend

⭐⭐

Sack Pioli

Sack Pioli

Bohemian Rhapsody

⭐⭐

Phase 3

Milan Legend

Sack Pioli

Milansochist