Never gave closure to this thread. No one really voted after week 38, so I'll take this as the final standings.
1. Bakayoko: 25
1. Donnarumma: 25
3. Romagnoli: 19
4. Suso: 17
5. Cutrone: 14
6. Calhanoglu: 13
6. Kessie: 13
8. Piatek: 11
9. Castillejo: 8
10. Higuain: 7
11. Paqueta: 6
12. Abate: 5
12. Calabria: 5
12. Biglia: 5
12: Musacchio: 5
16: Reina: 4
17. Borini: 3
17. Bonaventura: 3
19. Rodriguez: 2
19: Conti: 2
21. Laxalt: 1
20. Zapata: 1
According to R&B, best Milan players 2018-19 were Bakayoko and Donnarumma.