Top 3 Discussion Thread

Sod-Lod · Oct 4, 2012

MilanMB said:
I'm sorry, soddy... <3 u

<3 u 2 MMB

ulladullau · Oct 5, 2012

In the 8 games voted on so far 24 of our 32 squad members have participated.
Only 4 players are yet to poll a single point from our members.

They are:
Nocerino - Played in 7 games :eek:

Constant - 4 games
Niang - 1 game
Traore -1 game

Maybe someone should tell Allegri about Nocerino :lol:

MilanMB · Oct 5, 2012

ulladullau said:
In the 8 games voted on so far 24 of our 32 squad members have participated.
Only 4 players are yet to poll a single point from our members.

They are:
Nocerino - Played in 7 games
Constant - 4 games
Niang - 1 game
Traore -1 game

Maybe someone should tell Allegri about Nocerino

imo, in cases like this, instead of bashing the coach for picking nocerino, it's more interesting to try and figure out WHY he plays him... he may be bad in our layman's perspective, but he clearly adds something that allegri wants.

ulladullau · Oct 5, 2012

MilanMB said:
imo, in cases like this, instead of bashing the coach for picking nocerino, it's more interesting to try and figure out WHY he plays him... he may be bad in our layman's perspective, but he clearly adds something that allegri wants.

I wasn't really meaning to bash Allegri, just having fun. I think he has had a difficult time losing the best 2 players from last season and having to create a new identity for the team. His earlier formations weren't working and to his credit has changed to a style which, so far, looks as though it will get the team more positive results.

Back to Nocerino, he must be an important player in Allegri's system, otherwise he wouldn't get so much playing time, I fully understand a person doesn't get to coach a great club like Milan without being good at their job. So he obviously knows a lot more than us and trusts Nocerino to do the job he wants, whatever that may be.

MilanMB · Oct 5, 2012

ulladullau said:
I wasn't really meaning to bash Allegri, just having fun. I think he has had a difficult time losing the best 2 players from last season and having to create a new identity for the team. His earlier formations weren't working and to his credit has changed to a style which, so far, looks as though it will get the team more positive results.

Back to Nocerino, he must be an important player in Allegri's system, otherwise he wouldn't get so much playing time, I fully understand a person doesn't get to coach a great club like Milan without being good at their job. So he obviously knows a lot more than us and trusts Nocerino to do the job he wants, whatever that may be.

I wasn't talking about you...

i think all of us wonder why the hell noce is getting so much playing time. though people in general wants to bash the coach instead of trying to figure out why.

Goodfella · Oct 6, 2012

MilanMB said:
imo, in cases like this, instead of bashing the coach for picking nocerino, it's more interesting to try and figure out WHY he plays him... he may be bad in our layman's perspective, but he clearly adds something that allegri wants.

Well, in a 3 CM midfield his main rivals for the side CM spots are

Urby: less reliable defensively than him
Flamini: been injured/unfit for more than 80% of the games since Noce arrived and doesnt or didnt score as many goals
Montolivo: has been a starter whenever he's been fit
De Jong: same as above
Boateng: CAM
Muntari: was a starter when was fit, injured now
Traore: newbie, unknown
Constant: newbie, not as tactically aware as Noce
Strasser: injured, inexperienced

However it's pretty obvious Al would preferably not start him anymore. He's benched or subbed off in most games nowadays and his playing minutes will probably get fewer and fewer.

Sven · Oct 6, 2012

Nocerino play two roles when he is on the field. He defend the line with the DM's and then he attack along with the AM's. Make the team switch from a defensive 4-3-1-2 (or 4-4-2 cause El Shaarawy is tracking back a lot) to an attacking 4-2-3-1.

You need a lot of stamina and movement to play that role. In theory Urby could do that too... But last match he didn't for whatever reason and this was one of the reason why the midfield looked non-existent.

Mion-Moura · Oct 26, 2012

lol @ sage rating pazzo,acerbi and constant in the malaga match

MilanMB · Oct 28, 2012

Please, vote correctly!

Wrong:

1: Ses
2: Yepes
3: Pato/Montolivo

1: Ses
2: Yepes
3: No one

1: Ses
2: Ses
3: Yepes

1: Ibrahimovic
2: Nesta
3: Gattuso

Correct:
(3, not more not less, players that took part of the game.)
1: Ses
2: Yepes
3: Montolivo

Mr. Milanista · Oct 30, 2012

acmilan4ever opened the thread again just so he could vote. :lol:

MilanMB · Oct 30, 2012

Mr.Milanista said:
acmilan4ever opened the thread again just so he could vote.

Yeah just saw that :lol:

Wtf??

Sage · Oct 30, 2012

I can't believe some people can't even vote properly, it's not rocket science :lol:

Ultra Swan · Oct 30, 2012

MilanMB said:
Correct:

1: Ses
2: Yepes
3: Montolivo (OR Pato)

So who gets the point?

MilanMB · Oct 30, 2012

Ultra Swan said:
So who gets the point?

read sage's post, it's not rocket science...

KujaIX · Oct 30, 2012

Does it mean that you can vote for one or the other?

Keeping the brackets and emboldening 'or' doesn't really mean anything...

To me, it just looks like you can suggest two, but keep one in brackets with or in front of it.

MilanMB · Oct 30, 2012

MilanMB said:
Please, vote correctly!

Wrong:

1: Ses
2: Yepes
3: Pato/Montolivo

Correct:

1: Ses
2: Yepes
3: Montolivo (OR Pato)

i was comparing these...

you can only put 3 names.

Ultra Swan · Oct 30, 2012

Oh I get it... You answered Kuja, 'cause he's in the task force right? ... Jerk! :mad:

MilanMB · Oct 30, 2012

Ultra Swan said:
Oh I get it... You answered Kuja, 'cause he's in the task force right? ... Jerk!

he's a special kid, he needs help.

Kasoka · Nov 2, 2012

Shouldn't Bojan have two points instead of one?

ulladullau · Nov 2, 2012

Yes he should, no doubt MilanMB will fix it soon

MilanMB · Nov 2, 2012

Fixed

Falkryr · Nov 3, 2012

milanmb said:
standings after 13 games

1:
el shaarawy: 22

2:
montolivo: 9

3:
yepes: 8
de jong: 8
de sciglio: 8

4:
bonera: 6

5:
abbiati: 4

6:
pazzini: 3

7:
zapata: 2
emanuelson: 2
bojan: 2

8:
robinho: 1
ambrosini: 1
boateng: 1
abate: 1

rnb motm:

1:
el shaarawy: 5

2:
montolivo: 2

3:
bonera: 1
yepes: 1
abbiati: 1
pazzini: 1
de jong: 1
de sciglio: 1

1: Ses
2: Ses
3: Ses

MilanMB · Nov 5, 2012

Bojan, Monto and SES have had the first 3 spots the last couple of games #consistency

Congo Powers · Nov 9, 2012

constant not in top 3??

wow

MilanMB · Nov 9, 2012

Congo Powers said:
constant not in top 3??

No.

MilanMB · Nov 9, 2012

MilanMB said:
Standings after 15 games

1:
El Shaarawy: 24

2:
Montolivo: 12

3:
Bojan: 8
Yepes: 8
De Jong: 8
De Sciglio: 8

4:
Bonera: 6

5:
Abbiati: 4

6:
Pazzini: 3

7:
Zapata: 2
Emanuelson: 2

8:
Robinho: 1
Ambrosini: 1
Boateng: 1
Abate: 1
Mexes: 1

Whoscored.com player summary and match history.

justhope · Nov 13, 2012

MilanMB said:
Please, vote correctly!

Correct:

1: Ses
2: Yepes
3: Montolivo (OR Pato)

so how is this correct? 4 players mentioned.

mb chooses 3 he likes :mb:

MilanMB · Nov 13, 2012

NoHoPe said:
so how is this correct? 4 players mentioned.

mb chooses 3 he likes

No, i don't mean that!

only 3 players.

justhope · Nov 13, 2012

I know that.

but explain how is this correct.

Correct:

1: Ses
2: Yepes
3: Montolivo (OR Pato)

MilanMB · Nov 13, 2012

i didn't mean that u should write (OR Pato), so no, that's not correct.

1: Ses
2: Yepes
3: Montolivo

the (OR Pato) comes from my original post, where i said that Montolivo/pato was incorrect. and that people have to chose from monto ORRRR pato.

i don't even understand why i have to explain this shit. what's so hard to understand. put 3 fucking players, that's all.

what do you people think when u vote for example montolivo/pato? am i supposed to make the decision for you? 0.5 point to each?

Top 3 Discussion Thread

Milanese Dominator

Super Moderator

Serendipity

Super Moderator

Serendipity

Milan Legend

Super Moderator

Team Neymar

Serendipity

Milanista since Birth

Serendipity

Phase 3

.,.foREVer.,.

Serendipity

Mexes & Muntari fanboy

Serendipity

.,.foREVer.,.

Serendipity

Milan Legend

Super Moderator

Serendipity

The Champion !

Serendipity

⭐⭐

Serendipity

Serendipity

Milan Icon

Serendipity

Milan Icon

Serendipity