I always had the same opinion on Higuain. He is a world class striker but he's not legendary, he fails big matches like Zlatan does . I "hate" him to this day, like I "hate" Zlatan. I supported both though when they played/play for us. Am I happy that we finally have a top cf? Yes! Would I swap him for a merda like Icardi? Fuck no. Would I swap him for maybe a bit weaker but more likable (in my opinion) forwards like Cavani? Yes I would. I hate icardi also, but the difference is that he's not a WC forward
he's proven nothing. If you point out stats I point out players that hardly anyone would call WC with similiar stats, and even players like Toni who have much better stats and still arent considered top class, and if they are for stats only, that sets a really high bar and shitheads like mauro cant even compete. If we dont take stats, then icardi has literally nothing to offer.