The Red & Black Forums | An AC Milan Community The Red & Black Forums | An AC Milan Community The Red & Black Forums | An AC Milan Community

Go Back   The Red & Black Forums > AC Milan > AC Milan Players & Staff

AC Milan Players & Staff Share your views on the current AC Milan players & staff, from the seniors to the Primavera and even lower.

Thread Tools
Old 06-06-2005, 16:53   #1
National Team Player
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: NYC
Default Alex Bordoli Rates Milan


Dida - 8 - Apart from the costly mistake of letting in Smicer’s weak shot against Liverpool had an excellent season, saving Milan numerous
times, most notably both Champions League games against Inter Milan where he pulled off amazing save after amazing save to keep Milan in the
game. One of my candidates for player of the season.

Valerio Fiori - NR - Did not play this season.

Christian Abbiati - 6 - Did not play very often but when he did the opposing team usually scored a lot (even though when he played most of
Milan’s reserve defenders played also so it wasn’t all his fault). Has a lot of natural talent and probably will leave this summer in search of
first team football.


Lino Marzoratti - NR - Only played one game but the 19 year old showed a lot of maturity and promise for the future.

Cafu - 9 - Outstanding year for the 35 year old. He never stops running and provides priceless crosses for Milan. Provides an explosive attack
on the right side. You would never know he was 35 by the way he plays. My vote for player of the season.

Paolo Maldini - 7 - This guy never ages. Plays as good as any defender younger than him. Played in center and on left. A walking legend of the
game. His leadership is priceless. It truly will be a sad day when Maldini hangs up his boots. Another solid year from the captain.

Kakhaber Kaladze - 5.5 - Good attacker but not so solid on defense. If he could be more consistent he would be a starter. Probably leaving
this summer. Another up and down year for the Georgian.

Alessandro Costacurta - 4.5 - Bad year for the 39 year old. Too slow to keep up with the younger players. Did not show the consistency in front
of his own net he had last year. Should consider retiring this summer.

Alessandro Nesta - 6 - Okay year for the 29 year old. Not as consistent as last year and definitely not as dominating a defender. Will need to
return to last year’s form next year.

Dario Simic - 3 - Did not play very often but when he did the Milan defense was a disaster such as the Coppa Italia second leg against
Udinese. Disastrous year for the Croatian.

Giuseppe Pancaro - 4.5 - Injuries kept him on the bench a lot. Not as solid as last year.

Jaap Stam - 6 - An up and down year. Had great games (Man U) and horrible games (2nd Juventus game). I expected better from him.


Gennaro Gattuso - 7 - Runs his heart out for every minute of every game. A greatly underrated player. Another solid season from “Ringhio” and
has found his place in the Azzurri squad as well. Set to take over as captain when Maldini retires.

Manuel Rui Costa - 7 - Doesn’t get too many opportunities to play but when he does he is excellent. His goal against Brescia in Week 30 was
amazing. A solid season for a truly gifted player.

Clarence Seedorf - 5 - Horrible year for the Dutch midfielder. Too slow and gives possesion away too easily on offense and doesn‘t score very
often. He always disappears in the big games (Liverpool, Juventus). Galliani needs to consider selling him this summer and letting Vogel take
his place.

Andrea Pirlo - 6 - Is essential to the Milan team but was too tired this year. Didn’t get a break last summer because of Olympics and Euro Cup
and was plagued by injuries and fatigue all season long for Milan. Needs to take a long break this summer to get his energy back for next year.

Kaka - 6.5 - Struggled all year to find his form from last season but just could not find it. Okay season anyhow and should be back better
then ever next season.

Massimo Ambrosini - 6.5 - Didn’t get to play much but when he did was usually excellent. In my opinion should play more as he is one of
Milan’s best midfielders.

Vikash Dhorasoo - 7 - Outstanding player. Runs his heart out and has a lot of skill. Doesn’t play much. The question is: Why doesn’t he start?

Serginho - 8 - Amazing season for the Brazilian winger. Provides explosiveness down the left side of the field when he plays. His crosses are
priceless. Had a lot of crucial goals. One of my candidates for player of the season. Another good question is: Why didn’t he start?

Harvej Esajas - NR - Only played one game (in Coppa Italia). Looked decent.

Cristian Brocchi - 6 - Didn’t play much but gives his heart and runs a lot when he does play.


Andriy Shevchenko - 7.5 - The Golden Ball winner was not as fantastic as last year (that might partly be because he fractured his cheek bone
in the middle of the season) but he still had 22 total goals (most goals by a Milan player this season) including 17 in Serie A (possibly the
hardest domestic league to score in in the world) and 5 in Champions League (probably the hardest league to score in). Another excellent season
for Sheva.

Filippo Inzaghi - 5 - A disastrous season for “Super-Pippo”. Inzaghi missed most of the season with niggling injuries and only played in 15
games total this season. It seemed like every time Pippo would recover from one injury he would have another one. He only managed to score one
goal total this season (in the Champions League). Not what you would expect from one of Italy’s most prolific strikers. I give him a 5 for
always running and trying his hardest. I expect him back in full force next season if he can avoid injuries.

Hernan Crespo - 7.5 - Found his old form again. Scored some very important and great goals for Milan (17 to be exact) and took some of the
pressure off Shevchenko. Slowed down for a bit but came up big in the big games. I hope that Milan can sign him permanently this summer.
Fantastic season for the Argentine.

Jon Dahl Tomasson - 3 - Horrendous season for the Dane. Was so good last season but could not find that form again this season. Ten goals in
all competitions is just not enough. Needs to be sold this summer to make way for Gilardino.


Carlo Ancelotti - 4 - Did not win one trophy this season. With a squad of players considered to be the best in the world one would expect more
from this season. Has a better starting line-up and a better bench than both Juve and Liverpool but couldn’t beat either of them. He is way too
loyal to his players and does not let any new players break into the squad. He always sticks to the same starting line-up no matter who the
better players are at that moment. Reminds me of Trapattoni when he was at Italy. Also cannot hold leads. Milan are now famous for throwing away
enormous leads (Deportivo last season, PSV, Liverpool). Needs to learn from his mistakes quickly or needs to be sacked.

Alessandro Bordoli


What do u people think? This is very nice post season analysis for every player in Milan team. Some ratings are true, some smell of favoritism and some, well - questionable. Your opinions please...
newyorker is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-06-2005, 17:28   #2
Il Re dell' Est
Primavera Player
Il Re dell' Est's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: Belgium
Fav. Players: Sheva, Rui Costa

I agree for most of his comments, but not all of them.
But I think everybody has his own opinion ...

Forza Milan
Non Ti Lasceremo Mai
Il Re dell' Est is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-06-2005, 23:19   #3
AC Milan Legend
Seamus's Avatar
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: SF - CA - USA
Fav. Players: Anyone playing for AC Milan

I though he was pretty right on in most of his anlysis. Finally a good fan article about Milan by a fan on All of the previous articles written on Milan by 'fans' have been aweful, especially compared to this one.

The first article written by a 'fan' for Milan actually started by saying the guy was a Juve fan, but liked Sheva. That one was horrible.

Be civil to all; sociable to many; familiar with few; friend to one; enemy to none.
- Benjamin Franklin -

A slip of the foot you may soon recover, but a slip of the tongue you may never get over.
- Benjamin Franklin -
Seamus is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 06-06-2005, 23:49   #4
National Team Player
cosmin's Avatar
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Bucharest, Romania, Ghencea Stadium, Curva Nord

One thing i have to object about this. How did Pippo get a 5 and JDT a 3? I mean Pippo wasn't better that Tommason this season. In fact Tomason did score some important goals, Inzaghi did nothing.
cosmin is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-06-2005, 06:25   #5
Join Date: May 2004

Originally Posted by newyorker
This is very nice post season analysis for every player in Milan team. Some ratings are true, some smell of favoritism and some, well - questionable.
milanist is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-06-2005, 17:28   #6
yonggoh's Avatar
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Malaysia
Fav. Players: Kaka, Nesta, Pirlo, Gourcuff, Oddo, Maldini

Mine would go something like this...

dida - 7
maldini - 6
nesta - 6.5
stam - 6
cafu - 7
pirlo - 6.5
gattuso - 6.5
seedorf - 4
kaka - 6.5
sheva - 7
crespo - 6.5

JDT - 5
Inzaghi - 6
Kaladze - 6
Rui Costa - 6.5
Ambrosini - 6.5
yonggoh is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-06-2005, 18:53   #7
National Team Player
zantetsuken's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2004
Location: near Paris,France
Fav. Players: Shevchenko--Maldini

He is ery hard against Ancellotti.

Thanks Sheva and good luck
Maldini shows us the way to win others titles
Forza Milan
zantetsuken is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-06-2005, 18:55   #8
=alta tensione=
Inzaghi9's Avatar
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Bratislava,Slovakia
Fav. Players: Inzaghi, Kaká, Pato

well I must not agree with some...I don't thing seedorf was playing so bad in the begining he was our only scorer!!!hi has got a catastrophical performance against Juve but I don't think he was such bad whole season...
Inzaghi9 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 07-06-2005, 18:56   #9
Senior Team Member
kenichy's Avatar
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Honduras, now madrid
Fav. Players: fowler, maradona, pirlo

he over rated serghino and rui costa. they both had some solid games. and both had some terrible games and i mean terrible.
kenichy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-06-2005, 06:48   #10
World Cup Winner
ics_rk's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Indonesia
Fav. Players: Kaka, Sheva, Maldini, Baresi, Nesta, van der Vaart, Torres, Reyes, Pirlo, Gattuso, Pato

Agree with some but not all.

== Simply Milan is the best ==
==== Milanisti Indonesia ====
ics_rk is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 09-06-2005, 10:53   #11
Italian Tsar
Italian Tsar's Avatar
Join Date: May 2005
Location: India
Fav. Players: Maldini, Keane, Cannavaro, Pirlo, Imran Khan, Virender Sehwag

A fairly objective analysis, and especially hard on Ancelotti. To think Milan have now become famous for throwing away leads is just too much. Good thread.
Italian Tsar is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 10-06-2005, 23:52   #12
AC Milan Icon
Beemer's Avatar
Join Date: Apr 2005

A 4 rating for Ancelotti? Give me a friggin' break. That's just B.S. So I guess that if you don't win a trophy, then you're pretty much the scum of the earth, eh?
Beemer is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-06-2005, 00:13   #13
National Team Player
milan*7's Avatar
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Ontario, Canada
Fav. Players: Kaka, Inzaghi, Pirlo, Nesta

Cafu was overrated too. He may have done some great things in attack but was pretty average in defense. The good ratings for our midfield bench (Rui Costa, Serginho, Dhorasoo) are a bit suspicious too since neither of them played regularly. As for Carlo, one must remember that until May he was in the run for two major trophies. Surely he doesn't deserves a lower mark than Seedorf & Inzaghi...
milan*7 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 11-06-2005, 09:49   #14
Passion for *9*
AC Milan Icon
Passion for *9*'s Avatar
Join Date: Jan 2003

Who's that guy anyway ? I mean what are his credentials other than apparently contributing to a shitty website ?

Cafu 9 is really exaggerated, Dida was 8 until April but then became increasingly butterfingered when it counted most, Gattuso + Rui = 7 is way too generous, so are the 7.5 for Sheva + Crespo + 8 for Serginho..

Rating players who didn't play more than minutes is idiotic + Seedorf should be 3.

As you said, too lenient with some + too harsh with others = very very subjective.

Milan did not convince play-wise for the bigger part of the season + barely grinding out results doesn't justify ratings above 6 or 6.5... with 1 or 2 exceptions.


▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ ▪ perfection ▪ ▪
Passion for *9* is offline   Reply With Quote

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:44.

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2019, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
©2002-2011 The Red & Black Forums. These are fan forums and are in no way affiliated with AC Milan S.p.A.