Thiago Silva Thread

Pedro · Nov 13, 2009

Sod-Lod said:
It wouldn't happened in Dunga Management; he want from the team to play as one body, and Robinho + Pato are players that not get back for defending.

Pato said in an interview he wants to help defense. Well, I never said Dunga would do this, I have to agree I neither think so.

Sod-Lod · Nov 13, 2009

Pedro said:
Pato said in an interview he wants to help defense. Well, I never said Dunga would do this, I have to agree I neither think so.

Saying is something and doing something else

Let Pato contribute in defense in Milan which he could learn a lot especially he is in the Land of the Best Defense Techniques in the world!

SpartanMilan · Nov 13, 2009

Milano84 said:
1. is disputeable.. .he's called him up before

2. toulanan is a MUCH better passer which is y he starts

3. Possible, though fabiano is a much more natural #9 CF w/ strength

Domench doesnt like players who play in Italy (Frey should be their #1)

Pedro · Nov 13, 2009

Sod-Lod said:
Saying is something and doing something else

Let Pato contribute in defense in Milan which he could learn a lot especially he is in the Land of the Best Defense Techniques in the world!

Well, I am just going to trust Pato on this. Pato is speedy, has a decent header, don't know about his tackling, but he could really help if he wants to.

DSM · Nov 13, 2009

Pedro said:
I think this could be a strong Brazilian NT:

Robinho - L.Fabiano - Pato
Kaká
G.Silva - F.Melo
A.Santos - T.Silva - Lúcio - Maicon
J.Cesar

Kaka' does'nt defend enough to fit into that system unless Robinho & Pato are suddenly going to defend it won't work.

Players like A.Santos & G.Silva would'nt get in apub side & would'nt get in the squads of most top countries. It is funny that Dunga plays them.

Australiano1980 · Nov 14, 2009

My defense of NT team is..

Maicon..TSilva..Miranda..Aurelio
Hernanes..GSilva(Lucas)

Beemer · Nov 14, 2009

Milano84 said:
i bet i could make a combine brazil/argentine/italy SNUB team which could beat any team in the world....

cassano--pato--zarate

riquelme

hernanes---cambiasso

santon--tsilly--samuel--rafinha

dida

Dida has been retired from the national team since October 2006. Nice formation though.

centre said:
what? no anto? cmon its clearly a massive oversight that hes never been called up

Antonini has done nothing to warrant a call-up for Italy yet.

Redman10 · Nov 14, 2009

Ronaldo9 said:
yeah but Pato should obviously be the second or at least third choice after Adriano, not getting overlooked in favour of losers like Nilmar.

Then, Dunga would get criticize for favoring stars over players that are actually on form. The whole point of the Dunga era is to erase the fiasco from 2006 where the Stars were playing despite being out of form.

Pato is a better player than Nilmar but Nilmar has outperform Pato on the national team.

GreatKalu · Nov 14, 2009

MilanoMichael said:
Read his post again. Of course Pirlo doesn't belong.

MY BAD ... just saw Milano posting a formation without Pirlo and was massively disappointed. Rushed through the post, I guess.

Congo Powers said:
on the real:
who would have guessed T-Silly to impose himself so quickly? seems like since his first 'official' game he's looked 100% legit.

Like zZZz mentioned, Baresi gave his approval ... so I guess we should have been more confident about him. He's made a few errors, but overall, is turning out to be massive introduction.

Ronaldo9 said:
I bet if Lucio played for Milan and Thiago Silva for Inter you wouldn't have thought so.

Yeah ... so what?!?!

Anyone playing next to Nesta will look good

Pedro said:
I think this could be a strong Brazilian NT:

Robinho - L.Fabiano - Pato
Kaká
G.Silva - F.Melo
A.Santos - T.Silva - Lúcio - Maicon
J.Cesar

I've never thought high of Robinho. Sure, he's done well for Brazil, but of the few games I've watched of them, he isn't consistent enough. Certainly, I feel Pato on the left would produce more ...

----------------- Fabiano
-- Pato ---------- Diego ------------- Kaka'
---------- Melo -------- Silva/Lucas
Alves ---- TS ---------- Orangarrafe -- Maicon
----------------- Cesar

Only struck me now ... but all that talk about the Italian NT not being likeable because of the many JUVE players seems a bit out of context when the same people rave about a Brazilian side filled with Merda shits

Beemer said:
Antonini has done nothing to warrant a call-up for Italy yet.

I think he was being sarcastic.

Redman10 said:
Then, Dunga would get criticize for favoring stars over players that are actually on form. The whole point of the Dunga era is to erase the fiasco from 2006 where the Stars were playing despite being out of form.

Pato is a better player than Nilmar but Nilmar has outperform Pato on the national team.

Well said. In the end, its paid of for Dunga and Brazil. They are playing as a team, and not primarily on individual talent, which they used to in years gone by. A team will always be greater than individual talent.

Madridista · Nov 14, 2009

Well Pato is on form. And its not that Nilmar or Adriano are better workers. If anything Adriano is a star and was also one of the worst performers in 2006, why call up him then? Its obvius Dunga has some grudge about Pato, maybe because he left his beloved Internacional like that.

GreatKalu · Nov 14, 2009

Anyway, who are we to complain?

Both Pato and Silva get more rest + are at less risk of getting injured. I'm certainly not complaining ...

Forza Dunga

Madridista · Nov 14, 2009

Getting called would be a deserved reward for Pato and Silva's performances, Dunga refusing to do that as if he is trying to say they aren't playing good or arent good enough, thats unjustified

samir10 · Nov 14, 2009

atm only fabiano is at pato's level. kaka, robinho, elano and many others play bad. hell i'd take ronnie over robinho even kaka atm. silva is also in nice form, he should def play WC next year.

Madridista · Nov 14, 2009

its about recognition and our three Brazilians deserve to get that from Duncega.

ReBorned · Nov 14, 2009

TS is starter

MassterMark · Nov 14, 2009

and he finished, like i saw in last 5 minutes

how did he play?

Sod-Lod · Nov 14, 2009

TS Played very well tonight, he proved for Dunga his assets and Important.

I hope he does not hurt or suffer from minor Left Knee injury.

Pedro · Nov 14, 2009

Mine was quite attacking, true.

madtherchot said:
I've never thought high of Robinho. Sure, he's done well for Brazil, but of the few games I've watched of them, he isn't consistent enough. Certainly, I feel Pato on the left would produce more ...

----------------- Fabiano
-- Pato ---------- Diego ------------- Kaka'
---------- Melo -------- Silva/Lucas
Alves ---- TS ---------- Orangarrafe -- Maicon
----------------- Cesar

I was thinking also about dropping Robinho the last 24 hours. If D.Alves plays leftback well, he can go there. Not sure if Brazil should start both Diego and Kaká though.

L.Fabiano
Pato - Kaká - Elano
G.Silva - F.Melo
D.Alves - T.Silva - Lúcio - Maicon
J.Cesar

anilak · Nov 14, 2009

Sod-Lod said:
TS Played very well tonight, he proved for Dunga his assets and Important.

I hope he does not hurt or suffer from minor Left Knee injury.

Is his left knee havin any issues :conf:

. Why did u say that ?

I could not see the game. But, most of my friends here support the Brazilian NT and many of em were seeing Silva playing for the first time and were raving about his performance which was pleasing to hear

.

Madridista · Nov 14, 2009

Thiago was immense tonight, had the England forwards in his pocket for 90 minutes and he was so good that even allowed Lucio to venture forward lol.

But damn Nilmar proved me wrong. He was a constant danger on the left with his pace but partly because Wes Brown is such a lousy defender. I'd still choose Pato ahead of him but Nilmar probably gained a lot of confidence in Dunga now and will be hard to displace.

KujaIX · Nov 14, 2009

yeah, aslong as pato doesn't play. the other players will and convince dunga. this is what im afraid of. pato really should go to the world cup, he's better than nilmar in nearly if not all aspects but never gets picked even if in better form, it's really quite wierd.

the problem is dunga picks players based on the formation, but to be true either pato or dinho could play really well at the LW position for them, and pato could be a much better striker than luis fabiano.

Kuzimoto · Nov 14, 2009

"Thiago Silva - 8 - A man of the match performance at the back, proving on top of any challenge that came his way from England's front line, and not afraid to bring it out from the back when required, either."

happy for him! :cool:

Australiano1980 · Nov 15, 2009

Great game by Thiago.

For sure.. beetwen the 11 on the WC.

ReBorned · Nov 15, 2009

KujaIX said:
yeah, aslong as pato doesn't play. the other players will and convince dunga. this is what im afraid of. pato really should go to the world cup, he's better than nilmar in nearly if not all aspects but never gets picked even if in better form, it's really quite wierd.

the problem is dunga picks players based on the formation, but to be true either pato or dinho could play really well at the LW position for them, and pato could be a much better striker than luis fabiano.

Of course he will go... don't worry

KujaIX · Nov 15, 2009

ReBorned said:
Of course he will go... don't worry

i doubt it with that huge twat dunga in charge. adriano, nilmar, robinho, fabiano are all in front of him despite him beign better than all of them except maybe robinho.

Sod-Lod · Nov 15, 2009

anilak said:
Is his left knee havin any issues . Why did u say that ?

I could not see the game. But, most of my friends here support the Brazilian NT and many of em were seeing Silva playing for the first time and were raving about his performance which was pleasing to hear .

TS has suffered from pain in his left Knee yesterday but he continued playing to the end, although he was limping at his left foot.

MassterMark · Nov 15, 2009

happy for tsilva.

but pato should go to wc.
in dunga's reality he can be after fabiano, robinho & nilmar, but not after adriano & baptista :mad:

btw, what position did brazil have???

Sod-Lod · Nov 15, 2009

MassterMark said:
happy for tsilva.

but pato should go to wc.
in dunga's reality he can be after fabiano, robinho & nilmar, but not after adriano & baptista

The problem of Pato that he is not going back to defense as Robinho, but Dunga prefer Robinho cause he has more experiences in the field comparing to Pato; If you asked ME I would choose Pato Blindly over Robinho.

MassterMark · Nov 15, 2009

Sod-Lod said:
The problem of Pato that he is not going back to defense as Robinho, but Dunga prefer Robinho cause he has more experiences in the field comparing to Pato; If you asked ME I would choose Pato Blindly over Robinho.

but i would play WITH: robinho...fabiano...pato

Australiano1980 · Nov 15, 2009

Sod-Lod said:
The problem of Pato that he is not going back to defense as Robinho, but Dunga prefer Robinho cause he has more experiences in the field comparing to Pato; If you asked ME I would choose Pato Blindly over Robinho.

The problem with Pato is that he never responds well in NT.
He will get another chance before the WC.. i hope he take it. Diego probably will have another chance too.

Thiago Silva Thread

iedereen is gek

Milanese Dominator

Milan Legend

iedereen is gek

Milan Icon

Empire of Brazil

Milan Legend

Milan Legend

I still believe!

not exactly a lightweight

I still believe!

not exactly a lightweight

Moaaarr Attackers :proud:

not exactly a lightweight

Milan Veteran

MassterMark

Guest

Milanese Dominator

iedereen is gek

Milan Legend

not exactly a lightweight

Mexes & Muntari fanboy

Forza Milan!!!!

Empire of Brazil

Milan Veteran

Mexes & Muntari fanboy

Milanese Dominator

MassterMark

Guest

Milanese Dominator

MassterMark

Guest

Empire of Brazil