Lol that wasn't my point at all.
Also certain abilities matter less in certain positions
The great Brazilian fullbacks Alves, Carlos, Maicon and Cafu had a lot in common....all very fast, great dribblers and Carlos and Alves were good at free kicks....Overall they were more competent footballers than Calabria is now. This was my assumption. That their overall game was on a much higher (elite) level than what Calabria offered.
WRT your post, overall I think Vulture is saying that it doesn't make sense lol