Top 3 Discussion Thread

[MilanMB]

RULES :

1) Only ONE post in the "voting thread".

Or else people can double vote / votes can get lost in the thread. It's easy to see if someone has posted more than once in a thread, so don't try me.

So if people got some comments about the votes, they can put it in their initial post or in this thread.

2) Vote for 3 players and only 3 motherfucking players only. Are you happy now, sod-lod?

3) The players must have been taken part of the game.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Shortly after every game, I'm going to make an Top 3 Rossonero - AC Milan vs X - Day X thread. Like the first one we had against Sampdoria. Called the "voting thread".

The voting thread is going to be open ~ 48h days after every game.

---------

The thread you're reading now, is gonna be the result + discussion thread.

When I'm done putting together the votes in the voting thread, I will update the SECOND post of this thread

----------------------

If there's any questions or suggestions just let me know.

 

[MilanMB]

Standings after 48 games (Serie A, CL & Coppa)

1:
Montolivo: 46

2:
El Shaarawy: 42

3:
Balotelli: 19
Mexes: 19

4:

De Sciglio: 18

5:
Abbiati: 17

6:
Pazzini: 16

7:
Bojan: 14
Yepes: 14
Boateng: 14

8:
Constant: 10
Ambrosini: 10

9:
URL="http://www.whoscored.com/Players/14063"]Zapata[/URL]: 9

10:
De Jong: 8

11:
Niang: 7

12:
Bonera: 6

13:
Flamini: 5

14:
Emanuelson: 4
Abate: 4
Robinho: 4

15:
Acerbi: 2


RnB MOTM:

1:
El Shaarawy: 8
Montolivo: 8

2:
Abbiati: 5

3:
Pazzini: 4
Bojan: 4

4:
Yepes: 3
Balotelli: 3
Mexes:3

5:
De Sciglio: 2

6:
Niang: 1
Boateng: 1
Zapata: 1
Constant: 1
Bonera: 1
De Jong: 1
Flamini: 1
Abate: 1

 

[acerвιc wιт]

Someone should be placed in charge, have the thread closed, allow the person responsible to edit the one post which is displayed on a week-to-week basis, thread can only be viewed by other remaining members/guests.

 

[Pedro]

there should be mentioned a deadline obviously,

and MB can (partly) run this, he can count votes, and post ''now voting is closed'', would be appreciated if a mod then closes the thread, but MB can be in charge if he wants to, doesn't necessary have to be a mod (but can help) - don't expect mods to be interested Jasper eh?

 

[MilanMB]

i don't know when the deadline should be. 24h before next game like shevadaniel said wont work, because then we have mid week games. some voting will only last for a day.

I think 4 days is appropriate for every thread. no?

 

[Dottore Joey]

48 hours.

 

[Pedro]

i don't know when the deadline should be. 24h before next game like shevadaniel said wont work, because then we have mid week games. some voting will only last for a day.

I think 4 days is appropriate for every thread. no?

4 days sounds alright, shouldn't be longer than 4 days, maybe 3 days is even better, 24hours seem too short, 2 to 4 days, something between that, what do other people think?

 

[Nikfes]

2 days.

 

[Tidalwave]

3 days is ok

 

[Jasper]

Maybe ulladullau is a interested to help you.

It's important for someone to actually care about this. Meaning he has to take reponsobility to do this all the time. I remember there has been similar enthousiasm with Ratings and injurylist(?) that died once the original poster got busy/bored of doing it.

If you simply need to close the thread or sth like that just ask. But don't expect for someone else to make sure the right time is passed and shit like that.

 

[Pedro]

Most chance of this to succeed is when there are a few doing this together. Every game it has to be done, for a whole season long...

If both MB and ulladulla are interested, they can both do this, maybe someone else (too)...


I could help when the ones in charge are offline when one needs to be online, and if I'm online myself.

 

[Jasper]

Fuck, moved the discussion posts and now Kuja's is the first. I think the first post should include all the rules.

-e- shipped them to Probles + suggestions.

While every match-thread first post should include linnk to match-discussion thread, top3 rules discussion thread.

 

[Tidalwave]

final decision please

 

[AndreiX]

There should be threads with polls for all matches, the top 3 players should get points for each vote (1st -3p; 2nd-2p; 3rd-1p) and at the end of the season we shall see who's the best player.....

inspired by a foreign A.c. Milan site...

 

[beesanz]

That's okay. I believe 2 days after each match should be okay.

 

[MilanMB]

Maybe ulladullau is a interested to help you.

It's important for someone to actually care about this. Meaning he has to take reponsobility to do this all the time. I remember there has been similar enthousiasm with Ratings and injurylist(?) that died once the original poster got busy/bored of doing it.

If you simply need to close the thread or sth like that just ask. But don't expect for someone else to make sure the right time is passed and shit like that.

I can take care of this, unless shevadaniel wants to do it since it was his idea.

About the injury thread. If you move it to the players forum and sticky it i think people who usually posts about these things will take care of it. I never visit sites that report about injuries or rumours and such.

 

[Ultra Swan]

You lazy bastards!


As of Post #31:

1. De Sciglio - 55 points.

2. Yepes - 53 points.

3. Robinho - 32 points.

4. Montolivo - 17 points.

5. Boateng - 5 points.

6. Emanuelson - 4 points.

7. Flamini - 3 points.


...........................

Edit: Updated...

 

[ShevaDaniel]

Don't know if the discussion part is needed. But we need some place to put the results, or else someone's gonna have a hard time looking up every thread when it's time to declare the winner.

If people got any ideas then share it here.

The only rule so far is: Only post your vote in the other thread.

Can mods sticky this?

yey.my ideas has been accepted.

 

[Nirvana]

There should be threads with polls for all matches, the top 3 players should get points for each vote (1st -3p; 2nd-2p; 3rd-1p) and at the end of the season we shall see who's the best player.....

inspired by a foreign A.c. Milan site...

 

[MilanMB]

3 days it is then.

i'll post a notice in the voting thread when it's ~24h left.

 

[crazy4milan]

Oh finally golden letters have some use.

 

[Jasper]

Oh finally golden letters have some use.

Exotic Stevie G?

 

[ulladullau]

Maybe ulladullau is a interested to help you.

It's important for someone to actually care about this. Meaning he has to take reponsobility to do this all the time. I remember there has been similar enthousiasm with Ratings and injurylist(?) that died once the original poster got busy/bored of doing it.

If you simply need to close the thread or sth like that just ask. But don't expect for someone else to make sure the right time is passed and shit like that.

I can take care of this, unless shevadaniel wants to do it since it was his idea.

About the injury thread. If you move it to the players forum and sticky it i think people who usually posts about these things will take care of it. I never visit sites that report about injuries or rumours and such.

I'm happy to help you with this MilanMB. Just closing and tidying the threads, you can count and post the scores

 

[MilanMB]

I'm happy to help you with this MilanMB. Just closing and tidying the threads, you can count and post the scores

Great

You can close the thread around 21:00 CET (CL time). I'll be home from work 3-4 hours later to count the votes.

 

[ulladullau]

Great

You can close the thread around 21:00 CET (CL time). I'll be home from work 3-4 hours later to count the votes.

Thats at 5am for me
I'll do it when I get up.

 

[Mion-Moura]

flamoney got 3 votes i'm counting on de sciglio today.abate better watch out:smileani:

 

[Kasoka]

ADMINISTRATOR, PLEASE CLOSE THE THREAD. And the person who created the thread please read the rules of this forum.

WE ONLY HAVE ONE THREAD PER MATCH.

 

[Nasha]

what is the final decision? where to post votes?

P.S. Great idea ... I'd really like this forum to get more attention.

 

[MilanMB]

what is the final decision? where to post votes?.

Been talking this through with ulladullau. This is how it's gonna be:

Shortly after every game, I'm going to make an Top 3 Rossonero - AC Milan vs X - Day X thread. Like the first one we had against Sampdoria. Called the "voting thread".

The voting thread is going to be open ~ 3 days after every game.

---------

The thread you're reading now, is gonna be the result + discussion thread.

When I'm done putting together the votes in the voting thread, I will 1) post the result in this thread and 2) also update the SECOND post of this thread (first post is for rules and this instruction).

Example.

This week Robinho got 40 points.

1: Yepes: 64
2: Di Sciglio: 62
3: Robinho: 40
4: Montolivo: 20
5: Emanuelson: 6
6: Boateng: 5
7: Flamini: 3

If he gets like 30 points next game I'm just gonna remove 40 and put 70 instead, and also move him up / down the table if necessary.

We're also gonna have an individual table for CL.

Serie A + Coppa
+ CL
= Total

----------------------

If there's any questions or suggestions just let me know.

 

[Sage]

Yepes