that's exactly what we were saying at the time we won the scudetto
defending every game with such high line (and at that time small CB's) is just suicide
well now we have more size at the back with thiaw, but he doesn't provide the speed to make up for his fuck ups
this approach worked great for a few months when the team was in top, but it was never designed for long term success
good teams expose that routinely as expected
I think there's a few differences between what we're doing now (and last year) and what we did with the Scudetto.
I think teams attacked us more that year, and we dedicated more of our players to defensive roles, and it was not just Kessie, but we would play Krunic at CAM, our midfield rotated between Kessie, Tonali, and Bennacer, while our RW would work
tirelessly on defense whether Messias or Sales.
I don't think we really
baited teams into attacking us, rather, I think teams attacked us because they thought that's how they could get to us. They tried to fight fire-with-fire and match our press, and teams that sat back, we would exhaust them since our press was relentless, and we wore them down.
Now teams have figured it out that they can't play open against us, they just...
wait.
Juve, Inter, they don't press us in our half. Teams with two strikers are the best counters to our press because our counter-press has been figured out, but worse yet, we use Giroud in a way that doesn't suit him (or the opponent) and we expose ourselves to simple long-ball counters, which is what has ruined our games against Inter
and Juve.
Last year we beat Juve by letting Pobega Hulk smash their midfield to disrupt them, while we kept battering them, and once we got our set-piece goal, Juve's plan unraveled, and the game was over.
Pioli is being stubborn, he's not being patient, and he's putting out the same plan, no matter what confronts him. Which is killing us.
Any CB today, Thiaw, Ruben Dias, VVD, pick a CB, if you put them in enough 1-on-1 situations with a striker, even a bad one, they're going to make a mistake. Pioli puts our CBs on islands,
constantly.
Did Thiaw make a mistake? Yes. Yes he did. But when you play into the hands of an opponent, who wants to dive, who is as protected as Juve or Inter are... what are you doing?
I also think that while Mirante had a good game, I think our CBs (and our style-of-play) is dependent on a very mobile GK. Sportiello is no slouch, but we are a
completely different team with Mike in the lineup. The difference between last year and our Scudetto year? The presence of Mike.
Tata last year made errors, but, as you and your partner-in-crime pointed out: Pioli is playing a style that exposes Tata. Pioli did that
again with
Mirante, he didn't learn from last year. Mirante did his job, but we tried to maintain a suicidal high-line
and high press without a keeper who could come out. Mirante is 40, he played great, but having a sweeper keeper changes your calculus and your style-of-play.
Of course, you can still get scored on, it can still lead to errors, like against Inter--but the point is that Pioli does not adapt his tactics, at all.
So, no, I don't think it's about "good teams expose" us, that's not true. The teams we have struggled with are Inter and Juve, who both play like
shit, provincial sides with a 352.
But yeah.