So, I honestly wouldn’t be surprised either way.
My point is I long for us to do the conventional thing. What I see is unconventional thinking that doesn’t cohere because of either inexperience or unclear mandates. Being mavericks is great but you need unity at the highest level for it to work, a structure that lets you experiment responsibly. I’m not convinced we have that. Well, we don’t.
A traditional SD that operates without meddling would be evidence that the management has learned something from the last couple of years.
An established coach would at least signal ownership wants to run fewer risks. Not saying it’s bound to succeed, or that Italiano can’t do better than Sergio, but more that coaches or SDs who have been forged in the crucible of Italian football can do better in my mind.
You are correct, we don't have the foundations to experiment responsibly, they have tried to apply the theories of Beane in Barnsley and AZ with Redbird's Toulouse to the big time in Milan, and... it failed miserably.
I don't want it to sound like I'm disagreeing with you, more like: "yes, and..." with my thoughts and concerns.
I am annoyed that their "unconventional thinking" was just... shitty. It wasn't actually daring. Fonseca was not unconventional or daring--he wasn't doing anything astounding or unique at Lille. They went after Motta, but waited too long because they wanted to keep Pioli. They lost out Berta, because he didn't want to be at the whim of Furlani and Moncada, who fucked things up. And on and on.
Their transfers have been borne out of the most flawed squad-building theories I've ever seen--I cannot talk about their midfield construction enough, but I will spare everyone.
My fear is: I don't think they can do the conventional thing, because it would require them to cede control. They'd have to defer to the coach. They'd have to face that their gambles
and their "sure-thing" transfers haven't worked.
Does Allegri come in and accept Bondo, Terra, Emerson Royal, Pavlovic, Musah? Does he even want young players to develop, to begin with?
I don't think Furlani, Moncada, and Ibra have talked their way out of their execution--I think our owner is doubling down on his ego, that the methods he staked his reputation on will work. He is the one who fired the magical Maldini, and the farther away we get from that period the even more idyllic those times will be.
Even their attempt at creating "mystique" with their "ooo silence!" bullshit doesn't work because they're fucking up--and all it has done is that it has (if I believe they've actually done silent) is piss off reporters who no longer have their access-journalism to warrant being positive, so now they're all shitting on the management... which they have earned.
Bill Belichick's whole terse routine was only charming when he was winning, everything is charming when you win, but it just means that there are more knives out when you lose.
They've messed up so badly, on so many different levels, it makes my head spin.
I am praying that they stumble into fourth place.