Samaldinho
Milan Legend
- Joined
- May 22, 2012
- Messages
- 36,836
- Reaction score
- 114,060
This is fair, I just think that Pioli's mistakes as a manager are considerably worse than Maldini's in the transfer market.Two things. One you know I was pro Maldini staying. I am essentially judging he and Pioli the same. I never said Pioli didn’t make any mistakes this season along the way, I think this was a learning curve for the entire staff(top to bottom) on how to manage a team with raised expectations. So I’m not anti Maldini pro Pioli. I wanted both to stay and I think they together would have steadied the ship.
A couple things regarding the specific stuff from the season. One I don’t the season is quite as bad as you’re painting it. If last summer you were told Milan would make the CL semifinals and confirm a third consecutive top 4 finish, most of us would have said that’s more than fine. At the very least you would have been ok with that, nothing to cry over. Of course there were some very bad spots along the way, I’m not denying that. And the team got worse, which is something for concern and something Pioli needs to be talked to about from those above him. But I do think the team showed they still know how to beat the other big teams in the league, they still looked title challengers for half the season, they showed growth in Europe, and once again they showed some ability to win at the end of the season when their backs were against the wall. I have seen many, many teams fall from grace more than our current season just was. And that’s objective.
And I’ll add that if we had been eliminated in the group stages, I think this team comfortably finishes 2nd in the league. And to be clear, that’s not an excuse. This team won a title and we both know going as far as possible in every tournament is the goal from here on out. I just do think it highlights squad depth. A LOT of dropped points to worse teams were when Pioli rotated the team.
I guess I’ll just add my point is it’s not Maldini vs Pioli to me. Like I said, I was fine with both staying. I think they all deserved a summer to see if they can “correct” things.
For all the nitpicking on Maldini's transfers, the fact Pioli doesn't have a coherent style of play against teams that sit, is damning, in my view. The fact he doesn't seem to understand his own tactics, nor which of his tactical looks work best, is shocking.
For me, if Moncada's first market isn't an immediate success, then this is an instant failure. We should win the Scudetto, that is my expectation, because I have been told that Maldini has hindered this team with his poor transfers in 2022, and of course, the delays in the summer were not due to Redbird's lack of preparation, but Maldini all of a sudden.Exactly. RedBird used a subpar season to justify getting their own guys in and/or the old guard out. They would have waited as long as it took, but they pounced on the decisions made on the market and the 4th* place finish.
Maldini+Massara was doing fine, and who knows where the team would have gone had they had their mercato this summer.
In any event, I’m anxious to see how RedBird’s first official window looks and the results that play out. Anything less than CL qualification and CL quarterfinals run should be responded to by Milanisti with riots at Casa Milan.
I'm more flexible on the CL since it is a knock-out tournament. However, I'm expecting one Enzo, one Muani, and one Kvara level player from Moncada this summer--Moncada has never picked a bad player, I've been told, and since Pioli is helping him "pick the ingredients" I look forward to seeing Pioli's vision in full flight.
You are trying to take Kamada away from me bro? You're cruel.What if that’s Moncada’s doing? We’re all making assumptions. As much as we think we know, we don’t know nothing lol
Here's my prediction: if Kamada does great, it will be chalked up to Moncada. If he does badly, I bet it'll be stuck on Maldini.




