"He knows what he is doing."
Clearly not though. Even without rotation he still never learned to adapt against low block teams. There isn't an excuse for not having the players do to so, because we do.
There isn't an excuse that we don't have a squad to fight in two competitions, because we do. Despite Mike's longterm injury, the only other "big" injuries were Florenzi who we have adequately set in Calabria and Kalulu anyway, and Ibrahimovic. Is a 41 year old Ibra really the difference between this and last season? Now that I say it, possibly. Maybe Ibra was the key all along.
Pioli lost his magic where he could set up a game properly, turn around results, and drive the squad on through motiviation and passion. Look at last season, we didn't have the best squad but we were the best team as a whole. The spirit and passion of the team was there clear as day. That is now barely a flicker from some players, with others who look lost or disinterested. That is on Pioli. You also can't say he wasn't given no reinforcements. There are a few pieces who could've added more to the squad and failed either due to not working out (surprise: it happens to every team), or Pioli not utilizing them properly. Sure we could've hoped for more, but we knew with the late takeover there wouldn't be a big splash.
Fair points all. For me the ties against Tottenham and Napoli, the Serie A games against Lazio and Napoli showed what we're able to do.
People keep talking about an attacking system, a plan etc. To my mind we don't have a much better offense than the scoring numbers of our players tell us. AM, CF and RW is sorely lacking in terms not just of goals, but also the kind of skill, venom and performance that actually make us a bigger threat up front. Leao has 12 goals and 8 assists, which is pretty good but he even he could do better. Giroud has 8 goals and 5 assists, which would be strong numbers by our BACKUP CF. Saele 2 goals and 2 assists. Messias 5 goals and 2 assists. Rebic and Origi on a combined almost 8m net? EIGHT GOALS AND ASSISTS BETWEEN THEM. CDK 1 assists. Diaz with an OK tally for a backup, but he has been the starting man. My point is not that I think Pioli has done well this season, I agree with most of the criticism. But I am not holding him responsible for our attack being fucking terrible. That I lay 1) at the players, 2) at Maldini for trusting this attack and first at 3) Pioli. I am expecting a big overhaul, even in the title season we barely scored enough goals.
To my mind our defending(defense and midfield) was the corner stone of #19, and that's what I'm most disappointed about this season. Largely the same players supported by the launch of Thiaw have been an absolute mess. Both in defense and in midfield I haven't understood what our actual starting XI was until the final CL games this spring. It must have been tough to understand even for the players. To my mind Pioli has been constantly rotating in search for something that never appeared, an in hindsight poor decision that was multiplied by so many poor player performances. What is the starting CB pair? What is the midfield setup? Only in the Tottenham and Napoli games was this starting to become a little clearer, and we had almost ZERO backup for that constellation. Tonali, Krunic and Bennacer in the starting XI clarifies for me how little help there is in our squad depth. Vranckx, Pobega, Bakayoko, Adli, CDK offers NOTHING in terms of certainty and with the exception of Adli and Bakayoko that's been proved time and again this season. It doesn't mean I think we should give up on Vranckx or Pobega yet, just that these factors contribute to Piolis difficulty.
The failure of our Serie A season is a lot more complex than Pioli "not having a plan". He doesn't have the players to produce results either, outside of Rafa and Theo.
The most mindfuck of all of this is that I think this year will be almost more important to the growth of many of these players than the Scudetto season. What a reality check.
Let's hope there are some lion hearts left in the group, this squad has surprised us before. But for me: too weak a squad with too little threat has created this situation, it's not only Padre.