To be honest, I can’t explain it either. No one can. If Conceicao had the answer, he’d use it in a heartbeat.
I fully agree that squad selection can’t be the core issue. Like I said – the pattern is always the same, no matter who starts, no matter in what position.
But where I disagree is this idea that Conceicao carries no real blame. And this is coming from someone who’s usually harder on the players than most in this forum. I mean, if you make millions kicking a ball, in my naïve little world you don’t get to be a fragile flower just because the coach didn’t pick you or because you don’t have the balls to ask why you’re not starting.
Still – match preparation is the coach’s responsibility. And if we go behind in 8 out of 13 games, often looking completely lost for entire halves, playing like we just rolled out of bed and have zero clue why we’re even on a pitch… then yes, the players deserve criticism. But so does the coach who can’t seem to reach them, can’t motivate them, and – most worryingly – keeps failing to find the tactical key to unlock these games.
That is a big problem.
Maybe Conceicao isn’t as good a coach as we thought, even if he spent 10 years at Porto showing he can prepare a team to fight toe-to-toe with just about anyone on the big CL stage. Or maybe we’re simply dealing with a squad that’s run its course. Too many players who’ve reached the end of their Milan cycle, who just don’t have the spark or hunger anymore – the kind you need to go out and beat even a mid-table Parma away – or simply aren't good enough (Chuck, Musah and so forth).
Whatever the case, something’s broken. And right now, neither the players nor the coach seem capable of fixing it.