While, it is obvious that Tevez could have probably deliver us the scudetto, CL was a different animal even with Tevez. Quite frankly, I am kind of happy that we kept pato because if we got Tevez probably bonuses would have killed us. Ibra went from 9 to 12, Tevez was being offered 6 million plus hefty bonuses if we would have obtained the scudetto.
a) No one ever believed we would've won the CL with Tevez, would we have had better chances vs Barcelona? Yes and yes there's a chance to win it, there always is, but our objective wasn't to win it, it was to get as far as we could. A scudetto for us is enough of a reason to say we would've gain from selling Pato.
b) While I'm kinda relieved we didn't get Tevez, whom I believe would've left the club in 1.5 years for free maybe (he would've been 30, so I'm assuming he would've liked to leave to Argentina), and eventually wouldn't have make sense with the transfer approach we took... it's not like Pato is doing it for free. 4 mil or 4.5 mil + bonuses for a guy that's not playing nor is he making any sort of difference is worse than someone that'll make 6 but at least contributes, and Tevez would've had an impact, yes he would've become a headcase eventually, but well...scudetto. Needless to say Pato's value atm has decreased so much, Tevez is still better business than having kept him.
But oh well...what's done it's done.